3 Comments

A very interesting and thought provoking rebuttal. The concept of history as cyclical is also present in Walter M. Miller's majestic sci-fi novel "A Canticle for Leibowitz." I think that the "long defeat" and "long victory" need not be an "either or" dilemma but a "both and" synthesis is possible. From the perspective of a human lifetime, history may look like a long defeat, when it is really a series of repeated risings and fallings (as in "Leibowitz") until the final Unveiling ("Apocalypse") at the End of history. At some times in history it is best to make a tactical retreat from the World, like St. Benedict and the other founders of Western monasticism, only to advance in a counteroffensive at the right moment. I'm actually working on an article along these lines for another website. I've really enjoyed reading this discussion. Many thanks to both authors!

Expand full comment

Thanks Thomas! I have not read Leibowitz, but I'll look him up.

Expand full comment

Here is the link to the novel. It really is a science fiction masterpiece. I hope you enjoy it! https://www.amazon.com/Canticle-Leibowitz-Walter-Miller-Jr/dp/0553273817

Expand full comment